Credit card fraud costs merchants— and consumers—over $190 billion/yr.
Fraud prevention in our entire payments system – credit and debit cards – is based on a culture of detection, not prevention. As a result, identity theft costs Americans over $37 billion a year, and merchants in the US alone lose approximately $190 billion per year to credit card fraud. And yet this only accounts for the fraud we can identify. Something is clearly wrong with a system that allows theft to happen and expects American consumers to pay the costs of reimbursing merchants and credit card companies through higher prices. What are we doing wrong?
We’re using antiquated technologies. Credit and debit cards use magnetic strips – a seventy year-old technology – to hold sensitive financial information such as customer name, card number, and expiration dates. All this info can be easily copied and spoofed innumerable times to create hundreds of fake credit cards, or sold online for as little as $1 for each credit card identity. Financial services companies “prevent fraud” by using back-end analytics to catch the crime after the fact, instead of authenticating the card and the card holder are legitimate prior to making any transaction.
Chip-and-PIN users are protected globally from ID theft and fraud.
But why is it a uniquely American problem? Almost every other country and region in the world authenticates the card and the holder as being real prior to the transaction by using Chip-and-PIN credit and debit cards, based on the internationally recognized EMV standard. This upgrade for the rest of the world has resulted in a big problem for American consumers: international credit and debit card fraud has migrated to the United States due to our lax authentication protocols for payment cards. Here’s an example of the differences:
Mag-Stripe Credit Cards
Joe eats at a restaurant in Florida and hands his mag-stripe credit card to the waiter, who disappears into a back room with it to not only run it through the machine, but to copy the numbers down for his own nefarious use later. Joe then makes an online purchase with the same credit card, but the online merchant’s site gets hacked and they lose not only Joe’s credit card data, but that of hundreds of other people – all to be sold online on the black market. On the way to the police station to file a report, Joe is pickpocketed. The criminal then uses Joe’s credit card to purchase a $50 mag-stripe reader to make an additional 200 copies of Joe’s credit card to sell to his cohorts. While Federal law protects Joe against loss, it doesn’t protect the merchants who’ve been cheated, who then pass the costs of the fraud back on to consumers.
Chip-and-PIN Credit Cards
Joe eats at a restaurant in Rome and asks to pay the bill. The waiter presents him with a card-reader tableside, into which he inserts his card. The card’s onboard chip authenticates that the reader is legitimate, and the reader validates that the card is legitimate. (This step did not happen in Florida). Once it is confirmed that both the reader and the card are legitimate, Joe is required to enter his secret PIN, which authenticates that Joe is who he says he is. A thief that obtained Joe’s credit card number couldn’t create a fake card because he wouldn’t be able to counterfeit the card’s authenticating chip; likewise a pickpocket wouldn’t be able to use it because he wouldn’t have the secret PIN. Online fraud would be deterred by sites that require the card be inserted into a card-reader prior to its use. Joe is safe, the merchants suffer no fraud losses, and the savings are passed on to consumers through lower prices.
The future’s looking brighter...we’ll just have to wait until 2015.
U.S. card issuers are now slowly migrating to the EMV Chip-and-PIN cards, and beginning October 2015, credit card companies will shift the liability for fraud to merchants if they do not comply with the EMV standard. This will encourage many merchants to move to the more secure standard, bringing a windfall of benefits to American consumers, including improved international interoperability and a sizable reduction in fraud.
Click here to download the PDF version.
Secure ID News to Know
The Secure ID Coalition is thrilled to announce that it will hold a legislative briefing for Capitol Hill staff and issue stakeholders discussing the Medicare Common Access Card Act on Wednesday, March 23rd.Read more...
In light of Monday’s GAO report, which found that smart cards could prevent Medicare fraud in nearly one-fourth of cases, the Secure ID Coalition has published a new one-pager examining how these findings compare to CMS' current fraud-reduction efforts. Please click here to check out why a smart card would be a huge boost to reducing fraud in Medicare.
On Monday the Government Accountability Office (GAO) confirmed that smart cards would significantly reduce fraud in the Medicare program as detailed in the newly-released report—Health Care Fraud: Information on Most Common Schemes and the Likely Effect of Smart Cards. "This report represents another addition to the growing body of evidence that smart cards are not only an effective means of ensuring program integrity, but also a critical tool for administering benefits in a healthcare setting," said Kelli Emerick, Executive Director of the Secure ID Coalition.Read more...